|
The
Mummy Congress:
Science, Obsession, and the Everlasting Dead
by
Heather Pringle
An excellent book on the subject of mummies (and the science of mummy
studies) worldwide
|
The Mummy Congress:
Science, Obsession, and the Everlasting Dead
by
Heather Pringle
will make you wish you had
gone to college to learn how to study mummies--not that a college will
teach you such an occupation. Pringle has traveled around the world to
track down almost every important researcher working with mummies today.
Her entry into the world of
mummy studies occurs in 1998 at the Third World Congress on Mummy
Studies, held in Arica, Chile, home of the Atacama Desert and many
mummies. There, she meets many of the researchers who have spent their
lives pursuing what many believe is an odd occupation: studying the
preserved bodies of the dead.
In subsequent chapters,
Pringle visits many of these researchers in their workplaces and labs. She
reviews the nature of their research, airs their concerns and hopes, and
considers the value of their work (especially if it is
controversial).
Although the book reads
like a series of magazine articles that have been collected in one volume
(a minor problem that is easily forgivable), each chapter is rich in
details and provides an overview of a particular type of mummy or
mummymaking civilization in clear, understandable language. This more than
makes up for any structural artifice.
Stand-out chapters include:
(1) Johan Reinhard and Juanita (a critical look at what happens when then
National Geographic subsidizes mummy expeditions), (2) Vladimir Lenin and
his embalmers (a fascinating look at the need to make Lenin's mummy a
permanent political fixture), and (3) George Gliddon, a British
Egyptologist (a chilling discussion of a "scientist" who tried
to prove his racist views through the study of Egyptian mummies). Along the way, she
also tells a
number of intriguing mini- mummy stories (Jeremy Bentham, John Paul Jones,
and Enrico Caruso among others).
But my own personal
favorite is a chapter near the end that blends a discussion of the
Chinchorro mummies with that of the fate of the Inkan mummies destroyed by
Pizarro and later representatives of the Catholic Church. I have never
come across a clearer, more vivid account of what actually happened. This
chapter clearly shows Pringle's strengths as a writer.
My only real complaint
about the book is that Pringle does not document her sources throughout
the chapters (or even in endnotes). An extensive bibliography is included,
but if you'd like to know the source of her information as you read a
chapter, precious little information is given. Occasionally, the reader
can glean a source, but that is the exception.
Near the end of the book,
Pringle writes:
"Mummies
have always spoken to us on some deep primal level, and we are simply
unable to leave them alone. We love them and we fear them, we aspire to be
them and we dread that fate. But one thing is certain: we are powerless to
resist their potent appeal" (pp. 338-39).
I
feel quite the same about this book: though I have some minor reservations about
it, in the end I was powerless to
resist its many charms. Quite simply, Pringle presents an engaging, panoramic
view of the phenomenon of mummies and the emerging science of mummy
studies. That alone makes this a book anyone interested in mummies won't
want to miss.
The book includes 26 photos (most in color)
including Egyptian mummies (from Kellis and worth the price of the book
alone), Chinchorro mummies, bog bodies,
Cherchen Man and child, Incan sacrifices, St. Zita, and Stalin. The
cover photo is also eye-catching: Egyptian mummies lined up waiting to be
x-rayed.
|